diff --git a/DNSCrypt-Preference-Pane/DNSCrypt/DNSCrypt.m b/DNSCrypt-Preference-Pane/DNSCrypt/DNSCrypt.m
index f76511a..feb2bd8 100644
--- a/DNSCrypt-Preference-Pane/DNSCrypt/DNSCrypt.m
+++ b/DNSCrypt-Preference-Pane/DNSCrypt/DNSCrypt.m
@@ -232,7 +232,7 @@ DNSConfigurationState currentState = kDNS_CONFIGURATION_UNKNOWN;
     if (sender.state != 0) {
         [self setInsecureOpenDNSOn];
     } else {
-        [self setInsecureOpenDNSOn];
+        [self setInsecureOpenDNSOff];
     }
 }